Aliaa Magda Elmahdy, Egypt Activist, Poses Naked, Sparks Outrage (PHOTOS)


First Posted: 11/17/11 07:56 AM ET Updated: 11/18/11 05:40 AM ET


By MAGGIE MICHAEL, The Associated Press

CAIRO -- A woman activist who posted nude pictures of herself on her blog to protest limits on free expression has triggered an uproar in Egypt, drawing condemnations from conservatives and liberals alike.

Some liberals feared that the posting by 20-year-old university student Aliaa Magda Elmahdy would taint them in the eyes of deeply conservative Egyptians ahead of Nov. 28 parliamentary elections in which they are trying to compete with fundamentalist Islamic parties.

Nudity is strongly frowned upon in Egyptian society, even as an art form. Elmahdy's posting is almost unheard of in a country where most women in the Muslim majority wear the headscarf and even those who don't rarely wear clothes exposing the arms or legs in public.

Elmahdy wrote on her blog that the photographs - which show her standing wearing only stockings - are "screams against a society of violence, racism, sexism, sexual harassment and hypocrisy." The blog has received 1.5 million hits since she posted the photos earlier this week.

The posting comes at a time when Egypt, a nation of some 85 million people, is polarized between Islamists and liberals ahead of the elections, the first since the February ouster of former President Hosni Mubarak. Members of the most hardline Islamic movement in Egypt, the Salafis, have warned voters during their campaigns that liberals will corrupt Egypt's morals.


"This hurts the entire secular current in front of those calling themselves the people of virtue," Sayyed el-Qimni, a prominent self-described secular figure, said referring to Islamists.

"It's is a double disaster. Because I am liberal and I believe in the right of personal freedom, I can't interfere," el-Qimni said Wednesday night on one of Egypt's popular TV political talk shows, "90 Minutes."

The April 6 movement, one of the most prominent liberal activist groups that led the 18-day uprising against Mubarak, issued a statement denying claims by some on the Web that Elmahdy is a member of the group.

The posting prompted furious discussions on Internet social media sites, with pages for and against her put up on Facebook.

One activist, Ahmed Awadallah, praised her in a Tweet, writing, "I'm totally taken back by her bravery."

A supporter, who identified himself as Emad Nasr Zikri, wrote in a comment on Elmahdy's blog, "We need to learn how to separate between nudity and sex." He said that before fundamentalist influence in Egypt, "there were nude models in art school for students to draw."

Some 100 people liked his comment, while thousands flooded the site with insults. Some denounced Elmahdy as a "prostitute" and "mentally sick" or urged police to arrest her.

Elmahdy did not reply to attempts by The Associated Press to contact her.

Her move comes as Salafis have become more assertive in pushing their attitude that women should be kept out of the public eye, promoting a Saudi Arabia-style segregation of the sexes. On Salafi parties' campaign banners, photos of the few female candidates are replaced by drawings of a flower.

During a recent election rally in the Mediterranean city of Alexandria, Salafists covered up a public statue that depicted mermaids. Salafi clerics appearing on TV talks shows have refused to appear face-to-face with female TV hosts, unless the presenter puts on a headscarf or in one case, a barrier was placed between the two. Most recently, an Islamist preacher crashed into a university musical concert in a Nile Delta province of Mansoura, saying music was forbidden by Islam and that he wanted to "promote virtue and prevent vice" - the term used for the mission of Saudi Arabia's religious police.

Women rights activist Nehad Abou el-Qomsan said conservatives "keep adding layers to cover up the women and deny their existence."

But, she said, what Elmahdy did "is also rejected because posing nude is a form of body abuse."

Elmahdy and her boyfriend Kareem Amer, also a controversial blogger, have challenged Egypt's social strictures before. Earlier this year, they posted mobile phone video footage of themselves debating with managers of a public park who threw them out for public displays of affection.

Amer, who spent four years in prison for blog posting deemed insulting to Islam and for calling Mubarak a "symbol of tyranny," chided liberals who condemned Elmahdy.

"I think we should not be afraid of those in power or Islamists, as much as we should be worried of politicians claiming to be liberal," he wrote on his Facebook page. "They are ready to sacrifice us to avoid tarnishing their image."

Aliaa Magda Elmahdy, Egypt Activist, Poses Naked, Sparks Outrage (PHOTOS)

---

In this case, in contrast toi PETA's recent offerings, this is a valid form of protest in that the right of women to be sexually independent still has to be won.

What's the point of a right you do not use?

__________________
Unless otherwise specified, I am posting as a regular poster. When I will act as a mod, I'll make sure you're in no doubt.

Liberty. Otherwise you end up at "what is not required is forbidden, and what is not forbidden is required".

Huh? No one forced those PETA women to pose naked and no one force the agency to adopt that communication strategy...

__________________
Unless otherwise specified, I am posting as a regular poster. When I will act as a mod, I'll make sure you're in no doubt.

Originally Posted by contracycle

In this case, in contrast toi PETA's recent offerings, this is a valid form of protest in that the right of women to be sexually independent still has to be won.

Tr. Of course it's alright if the darkies do that sort of thing...

__________________
Standard disclaimer: the disgusting statements contained in this post are the views of the poster, and unless specified do not represent the views of the moderators or the site's owners.

Come on, look at the comments in the OP, it's bleeding obvious that the context is not the same. That's a completely dishonest argument.


Gilles:

Quote:

Huh? No one forced those PETA women to pose naked and no one force the agency to adopt that communication strategy...

I didn't claim they did. I merely pointed out that having the RIGHT to pose nude does not become pointless if you happen not to pose nude.

Originally Posted by contracycle

Come on, look at the comments in the OP, it's bleeding obvious that the context is not the same. That's a completely dishonest argument.

You're absolutely right that context isn't the same. It's always been the case that ethnic breasts don't count because they're educational. Look at issues of National Geographic from the 50s, or Victorian publications about darkest Africa. Third world titties just aren't a threat to civilised society in the same way that white ones are.

__________________
Standard disclaimer: the disgusting statements contained in this post are the views of the poster, and unless specified do not represent the views of the moderators or the site's owners.

Your argment seems astonishnglyu confused, conflating totally different issues, nor doe sit apprently have to do with anything. This issue, here, now, is easy enough to understand, and your only argument against it is another baseless ad hom directed at what you imagine, without any evidence at all, to be going on in someone elses mind. It is thus nothing more than a self-serving invention.

Sure it is. You said that Peta's protest is "invalid" (whatever that's supposed to mean) because they already have a right to get naked in public.

To which I say: Oh yeah? Tried it lately, have you? Even the Peta posters cover up the naughty bits because otherwise they'd just be censored. Mild as they are they still cause howls of outrage. Non-threatening Arab boobs, on the other hand, as this story demostrates, are good to go.

__________________
Standard disclaimer: the disgusting statements contained in this post are the views of the poster, and unless specified do not represent the views of the moderators or the site's owners.

PETA wasn't doing anything unusual. You can see boobs on page 3 of the Sun, a different pair every day. So PETA's action was in no way challenging to the status quo. Arab boobs in Egypt are definitely threatening, and do challenge the status quo in Egypt, as the responses to them cited in the OP show.