From SwissInfo

Cheap strawberry imports targeted by campaign

Simon Bradley
swissinfo.ch
Apr 17, 2010 - 10:32


Huge boxes of cut-price juicy strawberries imported from Spain and sold in Swiss supermarkets have been hitting the headlines this week.

Campaigners say it is not the strawberry season and have been drawing attention to the social and environmental impact of such imports.

The Senate will examine five cantonal motions calling for bans on unacceptable imports next week.

Although they are cheap, fruit and vegetables imported from southern Europe hide other costs, argue the Platform for Sustainable Social Agriculture and a coalition of parliamentarians, which together launched a protest campaign outside supermarkets in eight French-speaking cities on Tuesday.

Huge industrial farms in places like Almeria, El Ejido and Huelva in southern Spain or Rosarno in southern Italy employ illegal immigrants mainly from Africa or eastern Europe in “intolerable” conditions, the campaigners claim.

Workers put in up to 14-hour days for low salaries (as little as €20 - SFr29 - per day) and are housed in unsuitable accommodation.

Excessive pump irrigation and the heavy use of fertilisers and pesticides are also having a “catastrophic” environmental impact, the platform states.

“Agriculture is subject to the global marketplace which tends to go where conditions are cheapest to the detriment of the long-term vision of local agriculture,” Philippe Sauvin, the organisation’s secretary, told swissinfo.ch.

Sauvin said although Swiss farmers’ salaries were high for Europe, they were low compared with the Swiss average. He said these kind of cheap imports were putting Swiss farmers under pressure and salaries were being driven downwards.

“We really need to ask ourselves what kind of agriculture we really want and at what price,” he said. “Consumers need to set the tone.”


Bombarded with marketing

Dressed as strawberries, carrots and tomatoes, activists outside Migros and Coop supermarkets on Tuesday urged shoppers to buy seasonal fruit and vegetables produced locally.

Aline Clerc, an agriculture and food specialist at the Consumers' Association for French-speaking Switzerland, felt it was difficult for shoppers to avoid supermarket campaigns for heavily discounted imported fruit like strawberries.

“The consumer is bombarded by advertising for these cheap products whilst seasonal fruit and vegetables are not highlighted,” she said, adding that shoppers seemed to have “lost all sense” of the seasons.

There seems to be a certain degree of awareness about the issue among young shoppers, like 16-year-old Kevin Marquis from Geneva.

“At school in a geography lesson we watched a programme about strawberries produced in greenhouses in Spain and north Africa, so I try to pay attention,” he told the Tribune de Genève newspaper.

But the vast majority of consumers are not aware and just follow what’s on offer, said Sauvin.


Problem solved?

The campaign is taking place as the Senate Economic Committee prepares to examine five motions by cantonal parliaments from western Switzerland (Geneva, Vaud, Fribourg, Neuchâtel and Jura) calling for imported foodstuffs considered unacceptable to be either banned or at least properly labelled.

But the major Swiss supermarket chains Migros or Coop say these kinds of initiative do not make much sense and the problem is being solved.

They reject the campaigners’ arguments and say their producers and suppliers from places like southern Europe have to comply with very strict standards governing social and environmental production conditions, in particular the GlobalGap, GRASP and BSCI labels.

But Sauvin said this private labelling system was purely cosmetic, intended to dilute the problem and to weaken rules that should be written into national laws and international conventions controlled by states.

Benno Huber, a major strawberry producer from canton Valais, said people should not be too hard on the supermarkets, which are active on behalf of local products.

“When our strawberries appear on the market the big chains cut their imports to sell our products, at least in Valais,” he told the Le Nouvelliste newspaper.

The problem is an international one, he said, where globalisation imposes frenetic competition between producers and smashes borders while ignoring the social costs.

“The day Switzerland joins Europe you can say goodbye to Swiss farming, particularly specialised products,” he added.

My wife and I went shopping today. We just bought 1kg of fresh strawberry from our local Coop for a price of CHF 3.80 (US $3.60) reduced from CHF 7.60.

I just checked. The fruit came from Huelva. They came not in a cardboard or plastic container, but in an open wooden box; thus, not only can we eat the fruit. We even got free firewood with it.

The article is right. These prices make no sense whatsoever. Someone in the chain is selling at a loss.

Deregulation has generally skewed the markets to a point, where sooner rather than later, something is gonna give.

Just last week, I bought a plane ticket to fly to Paris in early June for a research meeting. Usually, I take the train when going to Paris, but this time around, the schedule didn't work out.

Furthermore, flying is now considerably cheaper than traveling by train, which is probably the reason, why the train connections get poorer every year.

I paid for my plane ticket US $176.60. However, out of this money, $159.60 were paid for airport taxes and fuel charges. The airline itself (Air France) gets $17. How the hell can they fly me from Zurich to Paris and back for $17 without running a loss?

These prices simply make no sense!

Quote:

Furthermore, flying is now considerably cheaper than traveling by train, which is probably the reason, why the train connections get poorer every year. I paid for my plane ticket US $176.60. However, out of this money, $159.60 were paid for airport taxes and fuel charges. The airline itself (Air France) gets $17. How the hell can they fly me from Zurich to Paris and back for $17 without running a loss?

Same here, I fly from Northern Ireland to England half a dozen times a year, and aslong as I book a few weeks in advance the flights only cost about £5 each way, then the tax is slapped on.

It really hit home when I had to go to Edinburgh not to long ago, I could of flown there and back several times over for tge price of a return coach or train fare. Without having to worry about changing trains or countless hours on a coach.

But there's no way that can be sustained surly.

__________________

I have bought Spanish strawberries and to my dismay they were not ripe so I had to ripen them myself. Personally I shall go and pick my own in June as the strawberries and fruit are a lot tastier as piuck your farmers grow their products for taste rather than try to appease the supermarkets.

__________________
“Some people like the Jews, and some do not. But no thoughtful man can deny the fact that they are, beyond any question, the most formidable and the most remarkable race which has appeared in the world.”

- Winston Churchill - Prime Minister of Great Britain